The final tier of the year before finals! This set was actually pretty straightforward for me, with one exception: Lindsey Buckingham VS. Snail Mail. Valentine really took its lumps this year: It was eliminated in Tier I when it ended up in a showdown with Cynic. Unfair, really, which is why it got a second chance at life in Tier 5 and knocked out a lot of serious contenders, not the least of which was black midi!
But for the first time, Snail Mail ran up against an adversary writing in a similar style, and Lindsey Buckingham is, in my opinion, an overlooked genius. And even in the twilight of his career, he still has it. The b-side tracks on the album have the elegance of pre-Revolver Beatles, never mind the fact that he just burns it as a guitarist. Snail Mail put up a fight, but the judges rule for Buckingham.
Eastman Jazz Ensemble - Live! VS. DOMi & JD Beck - NOT TiGHT DOMi & JD Beck - NOT TiGHT
E
David Bowie - Scary Monsters (& Super Creeps) VS. Porcupine Tree - CLOSURE/CONTINUATION Porcupine Tree - CLOSURE/CONTINUATION
A couple of contentious decisions here, some of which
probably run counter to all logic. For
example, earlier this year, I dismissed the Eastman Jazz Ensemble. A return to the album, however, revealed a
level of excitement in the recording that I didn’t remember from before. That, along with a certain sense of personal
connection with contemporary big band recordings that I have not felt in a
while, edged it over the clear genius of Relaxin’.
The second, and the hardest, choice I had was with the black
midi VS. Snail Mail showdown. I have not connected with Hellfire in
the same way as I have black midi’s previous recordings, but I still have the sense
that I still just don’t quite "get it". Like LIVE!, Valentine was eliminated in January and got a fresh start in
the 5th tier showdown, and with its return came a greater
appreciation of Snail Mail’s unique songwriting strengths. It really spoke to me at a time I still found
myself confused by black midi, so I let Valentine pass. Hellfire received a coveted Fall Save,
though, and will return in the playoffs.
Eastman Jazz Ensemble – LIVE! VS. Miles Davis – Relaxin’
Eastman Jazz Ensemble – LIVE!
Paul Slavens – Alphabet Girls V. 2 VS. Colleen Green –
Cool
Paul Slavens – Alphabet Girls V. 2
Kate Bush – The Hounds of Love VS. Vanishing Twin – Ookii
Gekkou
Kate Bush – The Hounds of Love
Bali Gamelan Sound – Otonan, Gender Wayang VS. Limina
– Hidden Spaces
Limina – Hidden Spaces
black midi – Hellfire VS. Snail Mail – Valentine
Snail Mail – Valentine
Bjorn Riis – Everything to Everyone VS. Cardiacs – On
Land and In the Sea
Tier 6 is framed by the albums that passed through Tier 5, the bracket consisting of eliminated entries from January. These winners are now going against new music in the Fall. This was a new approach this year that I found greatly rewarding. It actually gave some of these entries new life and, in some cases, a shot at the Top 20.
Two difficult decisions this time around. The first one was Kendrick Lamar VS. The Freestyle Fellowship. There is no doubt in my mind that Mr. Morale and the Big Steppers is a groundbreaking album that innovates in unique ways. I have a real soft spot for early 90s hip hop, and To Whom It May Concern is such a pristine and outstanding example of the style that I just couldn't eliminate it. Lamar, however, received my first "save" of the Fall.
The second was Goro Yamaguchi VS. Tim Reynolds & Greg Howard. Again, I feel confident in saying that Sticks & Stones is beautifully textured and constructed, especially since is was essentially a recording improvised in 1988 in Greg Howard's bedroom. Conversely, Goro Yamaguchi's solo shakuhachi work is comparably monochromatic, his expressiveness is emotionally moving in ways that Sticks & Stones doesn't quite access.
Avalalanche Kaito – Avalanche Kaito VS. Leprous – Aphelion
Avalanche Kaito – Avalanche Kaito
Fantastic Negrito – White Jesus, Black Problems VS.
Flying Lotus – Yasuke OST
Flying Lotus – Yasuke OST
Sault – Air VS. Juliana Barwick – Healing is a
Miracle
Sault – Air
Kendrick Lamar – Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers
VS. Freestyle Fellowship – To Whom it May Concern
Freestyle Fellowship – To Whom it May Concern
Tim Reynolds & Greg Howard – Sticks & Stones
VS. Goro Yamaguchi – Kinkoryu Shakuhachi
Goro Yamaguchi – Kinkoryu Shakuhachi
Porcupine Tree – Closure/Continuation VS. Transatlantic
-The Absolute Universe: Forevermore
Now that the mid-year favorites have been posted, its on to
Tier 5, a bracket with a unique construction in this year’s eliminations. One of the tenets of the elimination process
is to provide every album I listen to with at least 5 weeks in regular rotation. During most of the year, this is an organizing
principal. At the very beginning of the
year, however, the sheer volume of new music is prohibitive. The albums back in Tier 1 only had two weeks
of listening opportunities before being subjected to a showdown.
Tier 5, however, is a revisit.It is constructed of all the eliminated
albums from Tier 1, intentionally matched to minimize stylistic clashes.These 24 albums were reduced to 12, a group
that will serve as the “control group” for the Fall eliminations.
Sound nerdy?It absolutely
is.It was also the best innovation this
year.I had a chance to look at this
music with just a hint of retrospect, providing deeper appreciation.This “check” tier has provided a couple of
them with a satisfying trajectory to the Top 20.
Curious yet? Probably bored. Oh, well - here we go:
Sufjan Stevens – The Ascension VS. Vanishing Twin – Ookii Gekkou
Vanishing Twin – Ookii Gekkou
Arushi Jain – Under a Lilac Sky VS. Snail Mail – Valentine
Snail Mail – Valentine
Eastman Jazz Ensemble – Live! VS. Emma Jean Thackray –
Yellow
Eastman Jazz Ensemble – Live!
Shubh Saran – Inglish VS. Leprous - Aphelion
Leprous- Aphelion
Juliana Barwick – Healing is a Miracle VS. Cindy – 1:2
Juliana Barwick – Healing is a Miracle
Colleen Green – Cool VS. The Red Locusts – The Red Locusts
Colleen Green – Cool
Flying Lotus – Yasuke OST VS. Gang Gang Dance – Saint Dympha
Flying Lotus – Yasuke OST
Tony Kaye – End of Innocence VS. Tim Reynolds & Greg
Howard – Sticks and Stones
Tim Reynolds & Greg Howard – Sticks and Stones
No clip available, but an improvised semi-ambient Chapman Stick and guitar recording worth digging up and finding ten years after purchasing. Not that I did that. But I did.
Transatlantic – The Absolute Universe: Forevermore VS.
Anathema – We’re Here Because We’re Here
Transatlantic – The Absolute Universe: Forevermore
Shadoko – Le Domaine de Seedmill OST VS. Limina – Hidden Spaces
Limina – Hidden Spaces
Bad Bunny – YHLQMDLG VS. Freestyle Fellowship – To Whom it
May Concern
Freestyle Fellowship – To Whom it May Concern
Between the Buried and Me – Colors II VS. Cardiacs – On Land
and In The Sea
The results of last few Tier 2 eliminations include:
M83 – Oblivion VS. Hollywood Burns – The Age of Saucers
M83 – Oblivion OST
Kalandra – The Line VS. Once and Future Band – Once and
Future Band
Kalandra – The Line
Tom McGuire & the Brassholes – Tom McGuire& the Brassholes
VS. Cynic – Ascension Codes
Cynic – Ascension Codes
Its usually the case that the “genre clash” showdowns give
me the most trouble, but even though that Tom McGuire album is the first funk-rock
album I have connected with in a very long time, Cynic is really hard to beat
right now.The synth bass on Ascension
Codes just rocks my legs.
No, this time around the most contentious showdown was
definitely Kalandra VS. Once and Future Band.Keep in mind that Once and Future Band was a big, big player last year with
Deleted Scenes, and that any real contender would have to deal with this
preconception.It is partially due to
the fact that I loved that album SO much in 2021 that the nearly imperceptible lean
towards a more traditional prog approach worked against them ever so slightly.Kalandra, on the other hand, has impressed me
from the first listen.I have found it very
difficult to let go of the idea of continuing my engagement with the album, so
it goes on.
This final tier is comprised of music that showed up in November
and December of 2021.The albums listen
to this time of year always gets the short end of the stick, because unless they
are particularly compelling, they don’t get the opportunity to stand the test
of time that others enjoy.To address
this, last year I instigated the “punt,” allowing these albums to size up in a round
against the Spring finalists.The
results from the first six of these Tier 4 showdowns are as follows:
Tears for Fears – The Tipping Point VS. Hans Zimmer – Dune OST
Tears for Fears – The Tipping Point
!
The Buggles – The Age of Plastic VS. Vodun – Ascend
The Buggles – The Age of Plastic
Squarepusher – Feed Me Weird Things VS. Beauty Pill – Sorry You’re
Here
Beauty Pill – Sorry You’re Here
!
Deafheaven – Infinite Granite VS. Soccer Mommy – Color Theory
Soccer Mommy – Color Theory
!
Injury Reserve – By the Time I Get to Phoenix VS. Amythyst
Kiah – Wary + Strange
Amythyst Kiah – Wary + Strange
HERE!!
Chassol – Indiamore VS. A.C.T. – Imaginary Friends
Chassol – Indiamore
By and large, there was only one upset.Chassol’s Indiamore was really, really compelling
back in December, and coming back to revisit it only reinforced its genius.Dune gave The Tipping Point a run for its
money, but despite its masterful creativity, it is most effective in its role
as a soundtrack to the movie and not as much as a standalone musical
experience.
Nearing the end of Tier 2 eliminations! The results for this week include:
Moor Mother – Black Encyclopedia of the Air VS. N.W.A. –
Straight Outta Compton
Moor Mother – Black Encyclopedia of the Air
Robert Aiki Aubrey Lowe – Candyman OST VS. Sault – Nine
Sault – Nine
Grizzly Bear – Yellow House VS. Tomahawk – Tonic Immobility
Tomahawk – Tonic Immobility
Several contentious showdowns this time around.Moor Mother VS. N.W.A. was a bit tough
because the influence of Straight Outta Compton is inarguable.Decades of hip hop and rap music relied on
its groundbreakingly brave take on the black narrative. It is also, I think, an
artifact of its time.Moor Mother’s take
is adventurous and contemporary.It
feels relevant.
Grizzly Bear and Tomahawk represented more of a genre clash
problem.Considered within their
respective music scenes, these albums feel pretty evenly matched.Where Grizzly Bear wins out in terms of sheer
detail, Tomahawk’s ability to convincingly swing between crushing thrash and spaghetti
western twang is phenomenal.Tomohawk’s vital
drive edged them out ever so slightly.
Even though I am tackling some Tier 3 showdowns, Tier 2 is still going strong! The next few weeks includes albums from the May Roundup:
100 Gecs – 1000 Gecs VS. Daedelus – Invention
100 Gecs – 1000 Gecs
Native Construct – Quiet World VS. A.C.T. – Imaginary Friends A.C.T. – Imaginary Friends
Japanese Breakfast - Jubilee VS. Laurie Spiegel – The Expanding Universe Laurie Spiegel – The Expanding Universe
This week’s contentious showdown was this last one. Japanese Breakfast’s keen pop is clearly more accessible than Laurie Spiegel’s two disc compendium of mid – 70s computer music. Especially with the lengthier and more challenging experiments lying in wait at the end of the second disc, it can feel a bit overlong. But the creative context of this recording is incredibly compelling. Visions of cables running from room to room between huge IBM tape-to-tape mainframes taps into childhood memories of my father writing COBOL for similar machines. The idea of these behemoth machines being used to make this music resonates with me in surprising way.
Laurie Spiegel herself responded to my showdown post, and rightfully called into question the value of flattening the artistic output of these musicians with forced competitions. My response on Twitter came out terribly out of order, and I wanted to record it here in its entirety.:
First of all, thank you. In the last two years of doing this, you are the first to call me out on what is an inherently problematic process. A bit of a thread to follow….
For a long time, I’d just pick out some album that I liked a lot at the end of the year, but I found that would favor the music that I happened to be listening to in December, and didn’t really represent my favorite music from THROUGHOUT the year.
So I eventually came up with this complicated showdown bracket system to add some component of empiricism to what is an essentially subjective endeavor. And although I agree that art is not a horse race, art does invite critique.
Unfortunately, the nuances of critique are often lost in contemporary “cancel” culture. Showing preference for one artistic expression over the other doesn’t necessarily mean that one is “good” while the other is “bad.” It’s way more complex than a “like,” which is what opinions have been flattened into.
In general, we have lost the idea that you can be both a fan and a critic. I’m a music educator, and as such I should be able to honestly compliment a student on a job well done while still giving them constructive criticism. Its OK for your favorite music to have flaws, and its OK to be moved by music that you find offensive.
While it may seem that comparing music in such a way (especially from different genres) negatively impacts my listening experience by forcing meaningless comparisons, I actually feel like it deepens my appreciation by framing my preferences in opposition.
Sometimes, its nearly impossible to make distinctions, but I find it gratifying to reflect on my connection with the music I listen to and really think about what resonates with me. I am also genuinely curious about other people’s subjective opinions on music. Putting these sometimes transgressive “showdowns” out there is really meant to invite discussion to broaden my horizons.
Although I admittedly rarely get discussion, it is even rarer that I encounter uncivil trolling, so I think that its worth it. And, as you suggest, any press is good press. If I can get one Japanese Breakfast fan to check out your music, I can feel like this whole wacky system is worth maintaining. In my mind, its mostly for fun.
The first week of Tier 3 results below! These will be spread out over the course of the next few months. There are super difficult distinctions on these showdowns that usually require some detailed explanation, so I am hoping to make clips for them as they arise.
The Anchoress - The Art of Losing VS. Beauty Pill - Sorry You're Here
Beauty Pill - Sorry You're Here
The Buggles - The Age of Plastic VS. Mononeon - Put On Earth For You
Alice TM – Little Bodies in Orbit VS. Tears for Fears – The Tipping Point Tears for Fears – The Tipping Point
Parliament – The Mothership Connection VS. Tom McGuire & the Brassholes – Tom McGuire & the Brassholes Tom McGuire & the Brassholes - Tom McGuire and the Brassholes
Amythyst Kiah – Wary & Strange VS. Marillion – An Hour Before Its Dark Amythyst Kiah – Wary & Strange
This week’s contentious showdown was definitely Tears for Fears VS. Alice TM, and its an example of a weird phenomenon that this structure sometimes brings to light. I had Alice TM pegged as a dark horse favorite early this year, and I have a history of resistance to some of Tears for Fears’ other work. I put The Tipping Point against Little Bodies in Orbit knowing that if it were to go on, it would have to prove itself.
And it did. Big time
My usual criticism of Tears for Fears centers on the way in which they often dance with overly clean, nearly sanitary production, resulting in lack of edge that borders on "Adult Contemporary." The Tipping Point has a LOT of edge, however, in its devastatingly personal content that sees singer Roland Orbazal wrestling with the tragic death of his wife. As much as I really love the unique vibe of Alice TM’s album, and it has no lack of personally revealing lyrics, several of the songs on The Tipping Point are emotionally moving in a way that I could not ignore.
Once I accepted that perhaps The Tipping Point is superior to Little Bodies in Orbit, it really opened up for me, and I quickly came to appreciate aspects of the album that I had ignored up to that point. I might not have had this revelation if I didn’t force myself to think about it in relation to another outstanding album.
Brendan Eder Ensemble - Cape Cod Cottage VS. Nejira - Blume Nejira - Blume
Wolf Alice - Blue Weekend VS. The Anchoress - The Art of Losing
The Anchoress - The Art of Losing
Mononeon - Put On Earth For You VS. Common - A Beautiful Revolution Pt. 2
Mononeon - Put On Earth For You
Getting into these later tiers assumes more and more difficulty. I have to very often eliminate REALLY great albums for the sake of the process, so to be clear, I am not in any way saying that eliminated albums are poor. Most often, its a matter of details or, admittedly, how I am feeling that day.
All three of these were tough, especially the Mononeon VS. Common. Mononeon's enviable artistry and unique vision edged him out over Common, but only slightly. In fact, I see Common as a potential year-end Top 20 entry, so it feels a bit premature for A Beautiful Revolution pt. 2 to be out of the game.
So, this year I am formalizing the "save" process. I will cite six "saves" from tier 2 and 3 eliminations this Spring, which I will narrow to three the week of June 1. I will do the same for the Fall. These saves will form a final round with the December roundup entries.
This "apples and oranges" process is often problematic, I know, but it produces satisfying results in the end. Having some level of redundancy makes me feel like I gave all albums the best chances possible.
Tier 2 eliminations continue with just two showdowns this
week.
Beauty Pill – Sorry You’re Here VS. The Caretaker – An Empty
Bliss Beyond This World
Beauty Pill – Sorry You’re Here
Soccer Mommy – Color Theory VS. Crying – Get Olde Second
Wind
Soccer Mommy – Color Theory
These were both pretty straightforward for me, although
mention should be made on An Empty Bliss Beyond This World.As an examination on dementia, it is
profoundly effective.It’s also deeply
disturbing.I have a lot of respect for
it, but I don’t think I’d listen to it for fun.Beauty Pill is often equally as unsettling when they addresses suicide, but nevertheless maintains a level of accessibility. That edged The
Caretaker out.
Tier 2 begins this week! The albums that passed through Tier 1 are now taking on new music from Feburary and March, heading towards a mid-year Top 10. Here’s how things played out:
Men I Trust – The Untourable Album VS. Damon Albarn – The Nearer the Fountain, The More Pure the Stream Flows Men I Trust – The Untourable Album
ABBA – Voyage VS. The Buggles – The Age of Plastic The Buggles – The Age of Plastic
Fire-Tools – Eternal Home VS. Liquid Tension Experiment – LTE3 Liquid Tension Experiment – LTE3
Ben Kweller – Sha Sha VS. Sharhabil Ahmed – The King of Sudanese Jazz Ben Kweller – Sha Sha
The most contentious showdown this week was Fire-Toolz vs. Liquid Tension Experiment. Fire-Tools is a project that I find really, really intriguing, but a combination of the album’s overall length and the ridiculous chops of the Liquid Tension Experiment tipped the scales in their favor.
This is the last week of Tier 1 eliminations! 48 albums have been narrowed to 24 - the first step in a long path to the top 20 albums of 2022! Here’s the results:
Arushi Jain - Under the Lilac Sky VS. Sault - Nine
Sault - Nine
Sufjan Stevens - The Ascension VS. Tomahawk - Tonic Immobility
Tomahawk - Tonic Immobility
Cynic - Ascension Codes VS. Snail Mail - Valentine
Cynic - Ascension Codes
Daedelus - Invention VS. Tony Kaye - The End of Innocence
Daedelus - Invention
There were a couple of contentious showdowns of note this time around. I really love that Arushi Jain album, so Sault’s win was a bit of an upset (even though I should not be surprised). The really tough one was Sufjan Stevens VS Tomahawk. I really respect Steven’s ambition as a songwriter, and the Ascension is masterfully textured, but it feels a bit overlong. Tomahawk’s energy and virtuosity won the day there.
The big winner this week was Ascension Codes. I had the opportunity to crack that open a bit this week and got really excited about it. The synth bass on that album is just incredible.
Next week begins Tier 2, which will begin to pit Tier 1 winners against genre-adjacent albums presented in the monthly roundup series. It's about to get interesting....
Soccer Mommy – Color Theory VS. The Red Locusts – The Red Locusts Soccer Mommy – Color Theory
Sharhabil Ahmed – The King of Sudanese Jazz VS. Bad Bunny – YHLQMDLG Sharhabil Ahmed – The King of Sudanese Jazz
Vanishing Twin – Ookii Gekkou VS. Laurie Spiegel – The Expanding Universe Laurie Spiegel – The Expanding Universe
Anathema – We’re Here Because We’re Here VS. M83 – Oblivion OST M83 – Oblivion OST
It was this last one that really caused me the most heartache this week. In many ways, the dynamic and expansive overlap between Anathema and M83 fire off similar parts of my brain, even though they come at it from way different angles. The closing credits “single” from Oblivion, however, really puts it over the edge. Fantastically emotional and explosive.
Common- A Beautiful Revolution pt. 2 VS. Juliana Barwick – Healing is a Miracle Common – A Beautiful Revolution pt. 2
Parliament – The Mothership Connection VS. Cardiacs – On Land and In the Sea Parliament – The Mothership Connection
Shadoko – Le Domaine de Seedmills OST VS. The Caretaker – An Empty Bliss Beyond This World The Caretaker – An Empty Bliss Beyond This World
By far, the hardest choice was Parliament versus Cardiacs. Despite the serious stylistic differences between these two, I felt like they were pretty equal. Parliament’s larger cultural influence edged them out.
Jon Anderson - 1000 Hands VS. Eastman Jazz Ensemble - Live! Jon Anderson - 1000 Hands
Emma Jean Thackray - Yellow VS. Moor Mother - Black Encyclopedia of the Air Moor Mother - Black Encyclopedia of the Air
Freestyle Fellowship - To Whom it May Concern VS. Perfect Beings - Vier Perfect Beings - Vier
The Anchoress - The Art of Losing VS. Tim Reynolds & Greg Howard - Sticks and Stones The Anchoress - The Art of Losing
This week's most most contentious showdown was definitely the genre clash between the Freestyle Fellowship and Perfect Beings. Although I really respect and appreciate Freestyle Fellowship's skills and tenacity, I can't ignore the amount of thought and musicality invested in Vier. Maybe my favorite prog release from tier 1!
If you want to hear more about that, I take requests! Sound off in the comments below.