Saturday, October 1, 2022

2022 Album Eliminations: Tier 6 Part 2

 


A couple of contentious decisions here, some of which probably run counter to all logic.  For example, earlier this year, I dismissed the Eastman Jazz Ensemble.  A return to the album, however, revealed a level of excitement in the recording that I didn’t remember from before.  That, along with a certain sense of personal connection with contemporary big band recordings that I have not felt in a while, edged it over the clear genius of Relaxin’.

The second, and the hardest, choice I had was with the black midi VS. Snail Mail showdown.  I have not connected with Hellfire in the same way as I have black midi’s previous recordings, but I still have the sense that I still just don’t quite "get it".  Like LIVE!Valentine was eliminated in January and got a fresh start in the 5th tier showdown, and with its return came a greater appreciation of Snail Mail’s unique songwriting strengths.  It really spoke to me at a time I still found myself confused by black midi, so I let Valentine pass.  Hellfire received a coveted Fall Save, though, and will return in the playoffs. 

Eastman Jazz Ensemble – LIVE! VS. Miles Davis – Relaxin’

Eastman Jazz Ensemble – LIVE!

Paul Slavens – Alphabet Girls V. 2 VS. Colleen Green – Cool

Paul Slavens – Alphabet Girls V. 2

 

Kate Bush – The Hounds of Love VS. Vanishing Twin – Ookii Gekkou

Kate Bush – The Hounds of Love

 

Bali Gamelan Sound – Otonan, Gender Wayang VS. Limina – Hidden Spaces

Limina – Hidden Spaces

 

black midi – Hellfire VS. Snail Mail – Valentine

Snail Mail – Valentine

 

Bjorn Riis – Everything to Everyone VS. Cardiacs – On Land and In the Sea

Bjorn Riis – Everything to Everyone

No comments:

Post a Comment