Thursday, October 10, 2024

2024 Album Showdown Results: Tier 6, Part 4



Chrystabell & David Lynch - Cellophane Memories VS. Bill Rieflin - Birth of a Giant

Bill Rieflin - Birth of a Giant


Cellophane Memories is must-have for any David Lynch enthusiast.  It sheds light on a different corner of his universe and, as is usually the case, unearths new perspectives as much as it conceals others.  It is, however, niche listening for the patient Lynch fan.  One could argue that Birth of a Giant holds a similar place in the King Crimson timeline, but the performances are more overtly charismatic (especially those of Robert Fripp).  Additionally, as a Tier 1 survivor, time has been kind to the album as repeated listenings have revealed deeper musical structures.




Allan Holdsworth - Metal Fatigue VS. Peter Gabriel - i/o (Bright Side Mix)


Peter Gabriel - i/o (Bright Side Mix)


Both of these albums are flawed masterpieces from top-notch artists, but i’o’s high points outshine those found on Metal Fatigue.  It looks like very soon, we will need to decide which mix of i/o, the bright or dark side, will represent Peter Gabriel in the finals.




Jack White - No Name VS. Polyphia - Remember That You Will Die


Jack White - No Name


Although I have had reticence with Remember That You Will Die this year, the album has grown on me significantly.  Jack White’s surprise release, however, recaptures the energy that defined him in an arresting way.  




Wesley Fuller - All Fuller, No Filler VS. The Lemon Twigs - A Dream Is All We Know


Wesley Fuller - All Fuller, No Filler


Big upset here,, especially as The Lemon Twigs were darlings due to the incredible artistic success of Everything Harmony last year.  That album may have hurt A Dream Is All We Know to a degree, because the likelihood that they would recapture the magic of that album was low and objectively comparing two albums released that close to one another is just plain difficult.  There is a sense, however, that A Dream Is All We Know was an attempt to nostalgically recapture an aesthetic rather than reinventing a well-trod style.  Fuller is a retro-rocker as well, but his playful nature and wry sense of melody is nearly irresistible.  



Viewer’s Choice Results


Chrystabell & David Lynch - Cellophane Memories VS. Bill Rieflin - Birth of a Giant


Bill Rieflin - Birth of a Giant



Allan Holdsworth - Metal Fatigue VS. Peter Gabriel - i/o (Bright Side Mix)


Peter Gabriel - i/o (Bright Side Mix)



Jack White - No Name VS. Van Halen - A Different Kind of Truth


Jack White - No Name



Wesley Fuller - All Fuller, No Filler VS. The Lemon Twigs - A Dream Is All We Know


Wesley Fuller - All Fuller, No Filler

No comments:

Post a Comment